Testing Wood Tonerings

 

New! New Rim Email Distribution List
Receive notification for rims available "offline" as they become available. Click here.

I use a proprietary rim tester that allows me to audition and record rims without having to make a complete banjo. I have devised the rating system you can see below. Unless otherwise noted, the sound clips are made by recording direct-to-disk using Cubase sequencer, an M Audio recording microphone and a Pesonus Firebox. 

Photos Description  Sound Clips/Evaluation
 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.
** Dalbergia stevensonii. See Grenadilla Policy.

- 12" outer diameter
- 3.0" depth
- 0.7" wall thickness
- Soft maple rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Moderate power. Balanced and very sweet.

Arkansas Traveles*
Flop Eared Mule*  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.
** Platymiscium yucatans. See Grenadilla Policy.

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.7" depth
- 0.6" wall thickness
- Soft maple rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Responsive. Overall bright, Good mid tones. Lots of sustain.

Arkansas Traveles*
Flop Eared Mule*  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.
** Platymiscium yucatans. See Grenadilla Policy.

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.9" depth
- 0.75" wall thickness
- Soft maple rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Good balance. Overall medium bright. Brightens after 7th fret. More brightness sustain would bring it closer to typical bluegrass tone.

Cripple Creek*
Fireball Mail
Home Sweet Home
Katy Hill*  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.
** African blackwod (Dalbergia melanoxylon). See Grenadilla Policy.

- 12" outer diameter
- 2.99" depth
- 0.66" wall thickness
- TImeless Timber maple rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Warm overall. Brightens as you go up the neck. Moderate sustain. Almost perfect. A little more punch down the neck would be nice.

Arkansas Traveles*
Flop Eared Mule*  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.

- 12" outer diameter
- 3.0" depth
- 0.6" wall thickness
- Maple rim
- Cocobolo tone ring
- Partial internal resonator

My Judgement:
Throaty and deeply resonant. Very pleasing timblre. Nicely balanced.

Arkansas Traveler *
Flop Eared Mule *  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.

- 11" outer diameter
- 3.0" depth
- 0.75" wall thickness
- Maple rim
- Cocobolo tone ring
- Partial internal resonator

My Judgement:
Responsive. Bright, but slightly throaty. Balanced. Excellent treble up the neck. This is a superior rim.

Arkansas Traveler *
Flop Eared Mule *  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.
** Dalbergia stevensonii. See Grenadilla Policy.

- 12" outer diameter
- 2.8" depth
- 0.7" wall thickness
- Maple rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Great bsss in double C tuning. Fun to play.  Reminiscent of minstrel tone, but not quite that deep. Plunky and resonant. 

Arkansas Traveler *
Flop Eared Mule *  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.7" depth
- 0.75" wall thickness
- Maple rim
- Cocobolo tone ring

My Judgement:
Bright treble notes. A little lacking in the midtones. Good note separation. Not perfect, but still a good rim.

Arkansas Traveler *
Flop Eared Mule *  

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings: M-Audio microphone and Fostex MR16 recording studio.
** African blackwood (Dalbergia melanoxylon). See Grenadilla Policy.

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.67" depth
- 0.6" wall thickness
- Soft maple rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Bright yet with sweetness. Great sustain, great balance and power  Wonderful clawhammer banjo with three finger-style potential. Sweet!

Arkansas Traveler *
Flop Eared Mule * 
Three-finger medly * 

 
 
 
 
 

 
* Recordings for the rim above were made with a Korg digital recorder. The recording exhibits more treble than the real sound. The reverb is the room's natural echo.
** Platymiscium yucatans. See Grenadilla Policy.

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.8" depth
- 0.56" wall thickness
- Timeless Timber birch rim
- Grenadilla tone ring**

My Judgement:
Responsive with a rich, full voice. The bass does not quite match the presence of the mid and upper tones. A different setup (bridge, etc.) might solve this. Great rim!

Arkansas Traveler *
Flop Eared Mule *

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.7" depth
- 0.75" wall thickness
- Cooperman three-ply rim
- African Blackwood tone ring

My Judgement:
Perfect sustain, excellent balance, moderate power. Good round peak rim.

Arkansas Traveler
Flop Eared Mule

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.7" depth
- 0.75" wall thickness
- Birch block rim
- Blackwood/Brass tone ring

My Judgement:
Like rolled brass but warmer. Bright, loud. More sustain than ideal..

Arkansas Traveler
Flop Eared Mule

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.7" depth
- 045" wall thickness
- Curly Maple rim
- Padauk tone ring

My Judgement:
Acceptable tone, but a little anemic. Perhaps lack of mass is the cause.

Arkansas Traveler
Flop Eared Mule

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 5/8" wall thickness
- Walnut rim
- Cocobolo tone ring
- Herringbone Purfling
- Cocobolo bottom edge

My Judgement:
Spectacular warmth and presence.

 Soldiers Joy

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 3" depth
- 0.71" wall thickness
- Timeless Timber Birch
- Padauk tone ring

My Judgement:
Good all-around response. A little lacking in power. Walls to thick?

Arkansas Traveler
Flop Eared Mule

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.75" depth
- 0.6" wall thickness
- Timeless Timber Maple
- Black and white purfling
- Ebony tone ring

My Judgement:
Bright and responsive. It'll be a good, dependable rim.

Run Johnny Run
Johnson Boys

 
 
 
 
 

 

- 11" outer diameter
- 2.75" depth. .625"  thick
- Timeless Timber Maple
- African Blackwood tone ring

My Judgement:
A joy to play. 
Clawhammer: All the cutting power you'd ever want without the harshness of a metal tonering.
Three Finger: Nice, but no substitutre for bronze. Treble notes are more credible than bass notes.

Clawhammer
Arkansas Traveler
  
Flop Eared Mule
Three-finger
Fireball Mail
Home Sweet Home